Earnings and Debts Matter
By Paul Lamont
November 4, 2011
From last month: “As for investors who fall for the ‘cheap’ sales trick, their buying creates the multi-week dead cat bounces like we had in 2008 and which we expect to have many times over the next few years.”
The dead cat has had quite a bounce off the October 3rd lows (when a survey of traders found that only 8% were bullish). But this kind of volatility is typical of bear markets. Four out of six of the Dow Jones Industrial Average's largest daily percentage gains were in the bear markets of 2007-8 and 1929-32.
Now (10/28/11), 61% of traders are bullish. This is the same number that corresponded with the July 25th 2011 high. (The DJIA lost 2000 points over the next 10 trading days.) In addition, the DJIA has quietly made three subsequently lower peaks (spring, summer and fall). Investors will soon realize that the cat is indeed dead.
“Eventually the stock reaches a peak, but the absence of bearish news, along with bullish sentiment, makes the crowd oblivious to the possibility of a major price reversal. While some analysts or market mavens preach caution, or outright gloom, the masses dismiss these warnings… At that point, investor attitude is again one of disbelief. But this time, the disbelief is that the long, upward price trend is over. Bulls still treat these declines as buying opportunities, believing the bad news to be only temporary. The disbelief persists. But as price continues to fall, more and more bulls are discouraged as their positions drop into the red. Investors who earlier bought more shares on price pullbacks are now reluctant to do so again. Soon outright sales begin. Disbelief has transformed into belief that the price trend is definitely down. Selling accelerates. Fresh lows are hit. One by one bulls turn bearish, and investors continue to sell. Calls for new lows are heard. Opinion is decidedly bearish, and the stock is once again on few, if any buy lists. The bottom is finally made.” – Contrarian Investing. By Anthony M. Gallea and William Patalon III. 1998.
“There Are No More Tools In the Tool Kit”
As we stated in February 2010’s Bernanke Fails His Own “Two Lessons Learned” from the Great Depression, “Instead of the excuses Ben Bernanke offers for the Federal Reserve during the Great Depression: “the Federal Reserve didn’t understand what was going on” or “they were pursuing very orthodox policies constrained by the gold standard”, investors should know that the market can render the central bank powerless.”
The Fed and the government can create short term distortions: QE2, cash for clunkers, first time homebuyer tax incentives, etc. But these moves are quickly and completely retraced when they fly in the face of supply and demand. Ultimately, the Federal Reserve will fail at propping up the leverage in the system because the income is not there to service those private sector debts. This will force investors to dump assets, bringing their price back into line with historical measures of valuation. If you do not understand this, feel free to email us and we will explain in more detail as it is critical to our investment strategy.
Ray Dalio of Bridgewater Associates, one of the most successful hedge funds (15% for his investors annualized over the last 20 years), agrees with this outlook. In his “A Template for Understanding” (a must read), he describes this credit cycle of typically 50 to 75 years in length (sound familiar?). He also gives us this great simplified metaphor:
“…if you understand the game of Monopoly you can pretty well understand credit and economic cycles. Early in the game of Monopoly, people have a lot of cash and few hotels, and it pays to convert as much cash as possible into property in order to profit from making other players give them cash. So as the game progresses, more hotels are acquired, which creates more need for cash (to pay the bills of landing on someone else’s property with lots of hotels on it) at the same time many folks have run down their cash to buy hotels. When they are caught needing cash, they are forced to sell their hotels at discounted prices. So early in the game, “property is king” and later in the game “cash is king.”
We have reached the point in this long cycle where many folks will be forced to sell their hotels at discount. With regards to timing, Dalio believes that “there are no more tools in the tool kit” (monetary and fiscal policy) to prevent this from occurring. And “no matter what is solved in Europe you will have a deleveraging” which “…means we’re going to have more debt problems.” Sure enough, just a few days later after Dalio’s Charlie Rose interview, European leaders were forced to agree on a 50% loss on Greek bonds which led to the failure of MF Global, the 7th largest bankruptcy in United States history. The sharing appears to be over as the debtors simply cannot service their debts.
Greek Bond Losses: A Double Whammy
With Greek bond holders taking a 50% hit, and the ISDA declaring the haircut ‘voluntary’ so as not to trigger an insurance payout, hedged bond investors have been hit with a double whammy. It is as if half of your house was burned down and the government then declares that there was no fire so the insurance company won’t have to pay you. It is no wonder that two days later MF Global filed for bankruptcy. They were a leading derivatives broker which was leveraged 80 to 1 (Remember May’s The Collapse of Leverage) with large bets on European sovereign debt.
We have to admit that even we were surprised that MF Global went down without any bailout attempted. MF Global was a primary dealer with the Federal Reserve (only 21 institutions hold that distinction) and was headed by former Goldmanite/NJ Governor Jon Corzine (D) who was rumored to be the next Treasury Secretary of the United States. It doesn’t get any more connected than that. Perhaps the admission that in the last days they were using client funds to illegally cover their European investments made a bailout politically unfeasible. Regardless, relying on bailouts is not part of our investment strategy. As we stated in July 2008’s We Prefer a More Secure Financial Institution: “So in our view, accounts held at Wall Street investment banks and brokerage firms that deal with leveraged players are not secure.” Stay away from the fast money – it’s usually yours going away quickly.
As most risk assets have completely retraced their initial gains after the loss agreement in Greece, more fundamental shifts are also taking place: “Oil giant Royal Dutch Shell said it planned to curb its investments in the European Union in future due to doubts about the bloc’s chances of recovering from the crisis.” It is no wonder. Europe expects to borrow money to save Europe from borrowing too much money. It also should not be a surprise then that they are having trouble coming up with the funds. Last week, the ECB was forced to cut a bond sale from $5B down to $3B for its promised bailout fund. This week, they were forced to postpone the sale due to ‘market conditions’.
“One question you have to ask yourself if you are investing capital today is: Does debt matter? Because if it doesn’t, go buy stocks, go buy houses, go buy bonds, lever up because everything is going to be fine - if debt doesn’t matter. But if it does matter, like it has for the last 3000 years every time, then you better think a little harder about how you are allocating your assets and why…” - Kyle Bass. (must watch) 1hr AmeriCatalyst presentation.
Just Don’t Look at Earnings
It is rare that we tune into CNBC for anything other than an audio-muted check of the numbers. However, on October 26 we caught this discussion between CNBC’s Simon Hobbs and Evercore Partners’ Ken Sena. (You can watch the video using the previous link.)
To set the scene, Evercore Partners’ Ken Sena is “constructive” on Amazon stock as he says it “will look very well for people.” Simon Hobbs (in a surprising and welcome change for CNBC) actually challenges him on his extremely bullish forecast.
As an aside, back in August we noted that Ralph Nader was demanding a larger dividend from Cisco Systems because his holdings in the stock were down over 70% in the last 10 years. Cisco Systems at the height of the Dot-com bubble of 2000 was valued at 109 times earnings. Last week, Amazon had a similarly high valuation:
CNBC’s Simon Hobbs: “The stock is trading at 107 times earnings. You believe, you believe, it should be, your price target is to take it another 30% higher. So you think it should trade at 130, 140 times earnings?”
Ken Sena, Evercore Partners: “Well I think you can’t even really look at earnings at this point. Because I think when you look forward to the next quarter, I mean, the earnings are sort of disappearing. And I think, Yes, I am disappointed in terms of the results. But, I think even Amazon will say their focus is dollar profit maximization as opposed to margins but even the dollars have disappeared. So I am not making a defense for, I am not defending their kind of current state in terms of their margins but I do feel when you step back they are experiencing top line growth rates of 40%+ and these are the fastest growth rates…”
As Ken noted, Amazon’s earnings have indeed been disappearing (chart below).
Chart from CNBC.com
So when you look at the chart that follows of their stock price, which has doubled in the same amount of time, you will see what kind of mentality we are dealing with on Wall Street. Remember Ken thinks the earnings multiple should be significantly higher at 130 to 140 times earnings. Just as a reference, the average P/E ratio is historically 15.
Earnings could rise exponentially to make this stock price cheap (hey, anything can happen), but we highly doubt it. Usually, when there is this kind of disconnect between price and earnings it is the price (and CNBC viewers) that bears the brunt of the move. Perhaps we should get Evercore Partners’ Ken Sana together with Ralph Nader to talk stock valuation.
“The secret to successful investing is to figure out the value of something – and then pay a lot less.” - Joel Greenblatt. The Big Secret for the Small Investor. 2011.
It also appears that MF Global hired Evercore Partners for advice as it sought a buyout in its last days.
At Lamont Trading Advisors, we provide wealth preservation strategies for our clients. For more information, feel free to contact us. Our monthly Investment Analysis Report requires a subscription fee of $40 a month. Current subscribers are allowed to freely distribute this report with proper attribution.
***No graph, chart, formula or other device offered can in and of itself be used to make trading decisions. This newsletter should not be construed as personal investment advice. It is for informational purposes only.
Copyright ©2011 Lamont Trading Advisors, Inc. Paul J. Lamont is President of Lamont Trading Advisors, Inc., a registered investment advisor in the State of Alabama. Persons in states outside of Alabama should be aware that we are relying on de minimis contact rules within their respective home state. For more information about our firm visit www.LTAdvisors.net, or to receive a copy of our disclosure form ADV, please email us at email@example.com, or call (256) 850-4161.