Credit Extreme Emotion
By Paul J. Lamont
Oct 17, 2006
For the last 11 days, MBH Commodities’ Daily Sentiment Indicator (DSI) has recorded a 90% or higher bullish reading for the S&P500 index. This is the highest 10 day average ever recorded in the 19 year history of this indicator. Investors are now more optimistic towards this index than they were at tops in late 1987 or early 2000, which led to falls of 35% and 50%, respectively. The NASDAQ’s sentiment is also at extreme levels. For the last 10 days, an average of 92% of investors surveyed believe the NASDAQ will go higher. What makes this even more amazing is that the S&P500 and NASDAQ indexes are not making new highs. With extreme optimism levels not seen in over 19 years in these equity markets, it would be wise to prepare for a historic sell off.
Why So Extreme?
Since, sentiment surveys are only recent phenomena, we do not have measurements for manias in the 1830’s or 1920’s. However we do have another method that gives evidence as to the size of the sell off that we believe will soon occur. According to the Elliot Wave Principle, the first echo of a major top coincides with higher sentiment among market participants than at the initial peak. It is similar to an emotional gambler with a “double-down” mentality. Odds (or economic fundamentals) are against the gambler but emotion overrides rational probabilistic thinking. The “I have to make this back or my spouse is going to kill me” mentality. Even mutual fund managers are bound by it. “I have to make performance…or my investors are going to sell out of my fund.” This prevents participants from exiting the market even when extreme valuations occur. Today’s investors are guilty of this as well. They are “hoping” for stellar returns like those in the late 1990’s to make back their losses. Of course, odds are against them. The same market emotion fooled investors in the bear market peaks of 1968 and April of 1930. Most continued to hold through the following declines that lasted longer than a decade. How large could the future sell off be?
When The Music Stops
Robert Prechter used the chart below in his October edition of The Elliot Wave Theorist to compare the bounce in the S&P500 since 2002 to the rebound after the 1929 crash. This chart shows just the first two waves after each major peak.
Most investors do not realize that the stock market moved in three phases after the 1929 peak: the initial crash, grinding bounce, and then the final downdraft.
“Paul came over to say hello. ‘It's a great change,’ he said sadly. "We do about half the business we did. So many fellows I hear about back in the States lost everything, maybe not in the first crash, but then in the second.”
- F. Scott Fitzgerald’s “Babylon Revisited”, 1931.
Here is the third wave or ‘second crash’ that lasted from 1930-1933:
The down wave that started in April 1930 corresponded with three banking crises and a fall of 85% in the DJIA. It is unfortunate that our banking system has again been weakened, this time by unscrupulous mortgage lenders in the recent housing boom. We believe that we are apt to repeat history’s mistakes because ‘emotion to participate’ (greed) overrides rational thinking. While most may initially dismiss the comparison to the beginnings of the Great Depression, they would also have trouble with the next chart also provided by Elliot Wave International in 2002.
Unfortunately, as you can see, price action from 1974-2000 corresponds quite well with the ‘Roaring Twenties’. During the 1920’s, margin and credit expansion moved stocks to record levels. Similarly, our boom has been based on credit, especially consumer debt.
More recently, home equity extraction (shown in chart below) and loose mortgage lending practices have added fuel to the boom.
As a result, financial institutions will come under severe strains as the credit bubble bursts. The rise of mortgage defaults will signal the beginning of this deflationary spiral. Unfortunately, interest rate markets are setting up homeowners for this exact scenario.
In the Short Run: Higher Rates
Recently, leveraged speculators have piled into long
term bonds driving down interest rates. The
Commitment of Traders reports that the bet by ‘Large Speculators’ in the decline
in interest rates is the greatest in over 10 years of data. Historically, ‘Large
Speculators’ extreme leveraged positions have led to losses against better
capitalized ‘Commercial Hedgers.’ With sentiment also at high levels in the 10
Year Treasury Note market (88.7% bullish- 10 day DSI, MBH Commodities), history
implies that the peak in bonds is near or already has occurred and higher rates
will be in store for at least the next six months. Higher rates will prevent
many from refinancing out of their adjustable rate mortgages. Reports from
Fannie Mae state that over $1 trillion dollars in mortgages will reset at
higher rates in 2007. Many
Our analysis shows that owning stocks, mutual funds, real estate, and long term bonds will lead to losses in the future. Given this outlook, holding 3 month U.S. Treasury Bills directly in your name at a financially healthy institution is currently the best option for investors. If short-term interest rates climb, investors will benefit from buying new T-bills at higher rates every 3 months. However, if asset values fall as the credit crunch begins, total principal will be protected by the full faith and credit of the United States Federal Government. At Lamont Trading Advisors, Inc. we specialize in the preservation of wealth. Please contact us to open your U.S. Treasury Bill account and protect your portfolio against volatility.
***No graph, chart, formula or other device offered can in and of itself be used to make trading decisions.
©2006 Lamont Trading Advisors, Inc. Paul J. Lamont is President of Lamont
Trading Advisors, Inc., a registered investment advisor in the State of